Who's in Charge When the Pope is Incapacitated?
When a pope is ill, resigns or passes away, who steps in? And who else helps lead the Holy See? Insight into Vatican City.
Who’s who at the Vatican?
Daniel Speed Thompson, University of Dayton
For more than two weeks, eyes have been on the Vatican, awaiting news about Pope Francis’ health. The pope has been at Rome’s Gemelli Hospital since Feb. 14, 2025, being treated for double pneumonia and other complications.
When a pope is ill, resigns or passes away, who steps in? And who else helps lead the Holy See? The Conversation U.S. asked Daniel Speed Thompson, a theologian at the University of Dayton, for some insight into Vatican City.
Who are the most powerful people at the Vatican, besides the pope?
The Vatican houses the central government of the Catholic Church and is also an independent city-state. The pope is both the head of the Catholic Church and head of state.
In order to govern both, he has the Roman Curia, meaning “court.” In modern terms, the Curia is the papal bureaucracy. It is an extension of the pope’s authority.
In Catholic doctrine, the pope has the highest authority in the church. He can exercise it alone or with the College of Bishops, made up of all the bishops in the world. Bishops named by the pope to the office of “cardinal” can, if under 80 years old, vote to elect a new pope. Some cardinals, but by no means all, serve in the papal Curia in Rome.
Besides the pope, curial officials who oversee important aspects of the church’s political and religious life are often powerful figures. For example, the secretariat of state, headed by Cardinal Pietro Parolin, oversees relations with other countries and international organizations. It also oversees the Vatican’s diplomatic corps.
The Dicastery – “department” – for the Doctrine of the Faith, led by Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, addresses questions about correct Catholic teaching on faith and morals. The Dicastery of Bishops, headed by Cardinal Robert Prevost, coordinates the nominations of new bishops around the world.
All these officials work under the authority of the pope, advocating for and implementing his agenda. For example, Prevost has suggested that all Catholics should be involved in the selection of bishops. This idea is linked with Francis’ call for a more “synodal” church: one that is less hierarchical and shaped by lay Catholics’ concerns and challenges.
If a pope can’t fulfill his duties, who steps in?
When a pope dies – or resigns, like Benedict XVI did in 2013 – the governance of the Catholic Church formally falls to the College of Cardinals. However, the authority of the college is very limited. On their own, cardinals cannot make any significant decisions concerning faith, morals and worship. Nor can they undo previous papal decisions or change church laws about electing a new pope.
All the heads of the dicasteries lose their office upon the death or resignation of a pope. The College of Cardinals serves as a caretaker government whose primary purpose is to prepare for the election of the new pope and oversee day-to-day workings of the Vatican.
One cardinal, known as the “camerlengo,” is responsible for confirming the pope’s death or resignation. He then assumes control over the pope’s residence and coordinates the funeral, if needed. The camerlengo also takes custody of the Vatican’s property in Rome and supervises details for the upcoming conclave.
The day-to-day business of the Catholic Church continues, but no big decisions can be made in the absence of a pope. The church cannot appoint new bishops, and the Vatican cannot start new diplomatic efforts.
Are officials at the Vatican often nominated to be pope?
Sometimes. Francis was a cardinal from Argentina before his election as pope and had not served in the Roman Curia. However, Benedict XVI, Francis’ predecessor, did serve as the prefect of the Congregation – now called Dicastery – for the Doctrine of the Faith. Some recent popes served in the Curia earlier in their career but not immediately before their election.
What do you wish more people understood about the Vatican?
Three things. First, the Vatican is unlike any organization in the world. Its religious mission and political status rest on nearly 2,000 years of history. This complicated story provides a unique tradition that anchors the institution of the Catholic Church, but can also block the church from critical self-examination and renewal.
Second, the Vatican is like every organization in the world. Vatican officials can be faithful to the highest standards of their religion, truly wishing to serve the church and the common good of humanity. But they can also be flagrantly immoral, even criminals, and careerist seekers of status or luxury. Francis has consistently called out priests and bishops who see themselves as somehow superior by virtue of their office or their ordination.
Finally, compared with the massive bureaucracies of modern governments and corporations, the Vatican is relatively small and not as wealthy as it is often portrayed.
Although the Curia manages a vast international organization, its resources are far closer to my own midsize Catholic university than to the U.S. government or Apple. Vatican City and the Holy See employ about 2,000 people, with an operating budget of about US$835 million.
Yes, the Catholic Church has wealth – and the ongoing problem of deficits and financial corruption. But the Vatican’s resources pale in comparison with what a modern state or large company can muster.
Daniel Speed Thompson, Associate Professor of Religious Studies, University of Dayton
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
CC BY-ND 4.0
Personal Note: How did Conclave not win Best Picture at the Oscars? It was probably the best movie I've seen in a decade.
NOTICE: I'm a verified affiliate for both Bookshop.org and Temu. In addition to my usual cultural literacy theme, I spotlight good-quality, fun, and inexpensive drones and drone-related items. I get a small commission for sales from links on my page. Links in the text portions are in BOLD and are a minor change to the article, not affecting its meaning or emphasis. I added said bold links to Bookshop.org to the original article, and they are my recommendations, not those of the authors of the article.
S159 GPS HD 8K Drone Brushless Motor with Memory Card, Wind Resistance, 360° Roll, Aircraft Folding, Follow Me, Screen Controlled, FPV Helicopter, Aerial Photography DroneToy, Gift for Boy
👉 item link: https://temu.to/k/u3gksxkqvj6
🎉 Coupon price[$110.49] -35%
[FIMI X8 TELE Drone] FIMI X8 TELE Drone - 5000mAh Plus Battery, 3-Axis Gimbal, 4K HDR 48MP 30x Camera, Professional GPS, 10KM High Quality RC Quadcopter
👉 item link: https://temu.to/k/uz6ju8wv2tr
🎉 Coupon price[$532.45]